Why monthly deposits earn less interest in the first year
Follow twelve month-end deposits through a savings example and see why applying the annual rate to the year-end contributions overstates first-year interest.
Method
A savings balance built up over the year has a different interest history from a lump sum deposited on the first day. A monthly deposit starts earning after it reaches the account. The last deposit has much less time to grow than the first. Match the timing before comparing a calculator result with an advertised rate or account statement.
For a simple illustration, start with zero, add 100 at each month end, and use a constant hypothetical nominal annual rate of 5% with monthly compounding. The model applies a monthly rate of 0.05 divided by 12. At each month end it adds interest to the existing balance and then adds the new deposit. The new deposit begins earning in the following month.
After twelve deposits, contributions total 1200. The future balance is about 1227.89, including 27.89 of interest. Multiplying 1200 by 5% gives 60, but that calculation assumes the whole contribution total was present from the beginning. In this example the first deposit earns for eleven monthly periods and the last deposit earns for none.
View data
- Contributions
- 1200
- Interest
- 27.89
Worked example
After twelve deposits, contributions total 1200. The future balance is about 1227.89, including 27.89 of interest. Multiplying 1200 by 5% gives 60, but that calculation assumes the whole contribution total was present from the beginning. In this example the first deposit earns for eleven monthly periods and the last deposit earns for none.
To check the result manually, start the balance at zero and repeat this step twelve times: multiply the old balance by one plus the monthly rate, then add 100. Retain the full intermediate precision. If your deposits instead arrive at the start of each month, each deposit earns for one extra period and the result changes.
<code data-no-translate>monthly rate = annual nominal rate ÷ 12
<code data-no-translate>future balance = monthly deposit × ((1 + monthly rate)^12 − 1) ÷ monthly rate
The 5% rate is a hypothetical nominal input. An advertised APY, a variable rate, daily balance rules, fees, taxes, and the bank’s rounding method can produce a different result. Use the actual account terms when checking a statement and keep deposits separate from earned interest when comparing savings scenarios.
View data
- Start with the existing balance
- Use the balance already in the account
- Apply one month of interest
- Multiply by one plus the monthly rate
- Add the month-end deposit
- Repeat for each of twelve months
Checks and limits
The 5% rate is a hypothetical nominal input. An advertised APY, a variable rate, daily balance rules, fees, taxes, and the bank’s rounding method can produce a different result. Use the actual account terms when checking a statement and keep deposits separate from earned interest when comparing savings scenarios.